All of you will have to help me understand how the scoring works but by seeing some of our club members names at the top says it all.
Again, Way to go to Brian, Karen and Glenn!
Congrats to Charlie and his partner Bobby for their Grand Reserve Champion award at the Winchester BBQ competition in TN. What places did you take in each category?
4th Chicken
9th Pork
1st Brisket
Ribs sucked according to the judges and they have been our strongest category
52 Teams
4 points from the Grand Champion
Congrats to you Charlie. I have sampled the brisket and if Jesus wanted to eat some brisket he would ask for Charlie's! The judges are full of chitlins' if they said your ribs sucked!
Will, I got my results today and I feel a little better about the results. I think the amber ale I sent was one of an infected batch I had based on their comments. The comments on my stout were fair, although I disagreed a little with their interpretation of the style. My IPA is the problem...I got a 43.5 and still didn't place...damn. I did get honorable mention, though. It would have been nice if they had listed that on the results website. From the comments I got I assume I would have placed with more "hop aroma". I don't know how to do that without getting a hopback as I had an ounce of hops at flameout and an ounce each in 2 different dry hoppings.
hey i sent you an email but you faired better than me i got 31(apa) 27 (ipa) and 25(blond which i was afraid it was past its time) anyway you did good with the hm due to my place number on apa was 14,898 and ipa was 10,567 blond place number was 6789. that is a whole lot of entries you did good.
Comments
wow way to go brian and
wow way to go brian and karen and glenn. thats some points for our midsouth classic
Way To Go
All of you will have to help me understand how the scoring works but by seeing some of our club members names at the top says it all.
Again, Way to go to Brian, Karen and Glenn!
Congrats to Charlie and his
Congrats to Charlie and his partner Bobby for their Grand Reserve Champion award at the Winchester BBQ competition in TN. What places did you take in each category?
Thanks Glenn
4th Chicken
9th Pork
1st Brisket
Ribs sucked according to the judges and they have been our strongest category
52 Teams
4 points from the Grand Champion
Congrats to you Charlie. I
Congrats to you Charlie. I have sampled the brisket and if Jesus wanted to eat some brisket he would ask for Charlie's! The judges are full of chitlins' if they said your ribs sucked!
weird that two beers that
weird that two beers that placed were "cardboard "and "confusing" tasting to other judges in another comp.
It's SOOOOOO subjective you
It's SOOOOOO subjective you just never know. I guess it's best to just enter ALOT of beers, knowing that something will stick!
Nice job folks... ;)
Nice job folks... ;)
Here are the results of the
Here are the results of the competition.
http://www.memphisbrews.com/extravaganz08/2008extravaganzaresults.html
Not sure about getting back comments. I'm figuring that usually takes some time.
CONGRATS to Glenn AND Brian
CONGRATS to Glenn AND Brian and Karen!!!!! Glenn has a 1st and a 3rd, Brian and Karen have a 1st, 2nd and 2 3rd's. Will and I each got one 3rd.
Will, I got my results today
Will, I got my results today and I feel a little better about the results. I think the amber ale I sent was one of an infected batch I had based on their comments. The comments on my stout were fair, although I disagreed a little with their interpretation of the style. My IPA is the problem...I got a 43.5 and still didn't place...damn. I did get honorable mention, though. It would have been nice if they had listed that on the results website. From the comments I got I assume I would have placed with more "hop aroma". I don't know how to do that without getting a hopback as I had an ounce of hops at flameout and an ounce each in 2 different dry hoppings.
How are you getting the
How are you getting the results so fast?
This was actually posted
This was actually posted under the wrong competition. We are talking about the Highland competition.
hey i sent you an email but
hey i sent you an email but you faired better than me i got 31(apa) 27 (ipa) and 25(blond which i was afraid it was past its time) anyway you did good with the hm due to my place number on apa was 14,898 and ipa was 10,567 blond place number was 6789. that is a whole lot of entries you did good.
Holy shit thats alot of
Holy shit thats alot of entries. Will you and Greg both did good if there were that many entries!